Hot Water Tank Rentals: Pros, Cons & Everything In Between

Posted by on November 25/2022 | 0 Comments

hot water tank rentals ontario

Having hot water in your home is almost as essential in life as having food on your table. Families use it for showering, cleaning, or laundry service, hot water is a modern convenience that is a vital service today.

Hy-Pro Plumbing & Drain Cleaning provides local professional customer service, same-day service, and 24-hour services for emergencies. As with most plumbing emergencies, a quick reply and fix will fix bigger issues down the road, enabling you to avoid a costly repair. We are here to help no matter the time or plumbing issue. Contact us today at 1-877-554-9776 to talk to one of our friendly staff and let us help you get it fixed.

When it comes to having hot water in your home, your options are renting a hot water tank or buying a unit outright. Renting and buying both have advantages and disadvantages, and it’s important to consider your specific needs and circumstances before deciding.

Renting a Hot Water Tank Pros Vs. Cons!

Seeing the pros and cons of renting and purchasing a hot tank will help you make an informed decision on your needs, budget, and reason for the hot water tank.


  • Lower upfront cost: Renting a hot water tank requires little to no upfront cost, as you only make a monthly payment for the rental fee. This can be a good option for people who do not have a lot of funds to buy a hot water tank outright.
  • Maintenance and Repair Included: When you rent a hot water tank, the rental company is responsible for any repairs needed during the rental period. This can save you money on unexpected repairs.
  • Upgrade Options: With a rental company, you can upgrade to a newer and more efficient one on the market without paying the additional price of the newer and better new hot water tank.
  • Convenience: A hot water tank rental is very convenient as the company you rent it from will install and remove the old tank if needed. You won’t have to hire an outside company to remove and discard your old tank, and you won’t have to pay installation fees.


  • Higher Overall Cost: Although renting a hot water tank may seem cheaper upfront from a monthly rental fee, you may end up paying more for the monthly rate over the long term than a new tank’s purchase price tag.
  • Limited Options: When you are renting a water heater, you are limited to the models and brands offered by the rental company. You also may be unable to find the type you want or need.
  • Rental Contracts: A rental agreement can be worded in a way that it’s difficult to understand and read and includes important conditions in the fine print that some may overlook. Read the entire contract through before signing it to ensure you understand the company’s terms and conditions.
  • Responsibility: While the rental company is responsible for the maintenance and repairs, you may still be responsible for additional and unforeseen costs, such as those caused by neglect and misuse of the tank. Additionally, if you move, some companies make it your responsibility to remove the rental tank and return it to the rental company before you move.

Purchasing a Hot Water Tank Pros Vs. Cons!


  • Lower Long-Term Cost: When you buy a hot water tank, you own it outright and don’t have to pay an ongoing monthly payment. Over the long term, this can save you money, making it more cost-efficient compared to renting.
  • Greater Selection and Freedom: When you buy a hot water tank, you have a wider selection of models, brands, and sizes to choose from. You can find the exact features you want or need for your home or business. Furthermore, you will be free to do whatever you want. Enabling you to customize it or upgrade it as you desire to make it more energy efficient.
  • Investment: Buying a hot water tank can be seen as an investment in your home or business. It may increase the value of your home, save you money on energy bills, and potentially save you on home insurance.


  • Higher Upfront Costs: When you purchase a brand-new hot water tank, you will need to pay for the entire thing at that time. This can be a barrier for those that don’t have funds to buy a new tank outright.
  • Limited Warranty: Many new hot water tanks come with a limited warranty and may not cover all unforeseen costs, such as repairs and replacements that are needed over time. You will be required to pay out-of-pocket for the unexpected repairs that happen if the warranty doesn’t cover them.
  • Maintenance, Repairs, and Disposal: Outside of any minor things covered by the warranty, you’re responsible for covering all the repairs and maintenance that the hot water tank will need in its lifetime. This can get costly and time-consuming. Plus, when you are replacing a hot water tank, you are responsible for disposing of the old tank. This can be an additional cost and hassle to consider.

Maximizing The Budget: Is Hot Water Tank Rental The Right Choice For You?

Hot water tank rental can be a convenient choice for those who do not have the funds for an upfront purchase or unforeseen costs and someone who values the convenience of having repairs and maintenance handled by the rental company. However, it is important to review ”the pros and cons and weigh carefully all conditions outlined in a rental contract before deciding. Those who prefer greater selection, more control over choices, and lower long-term costs will find purchasing a new tank to be the option for them.

If you are considering a hot water tank rental, research the rental companies, compare monthly costs and models, and read reviews from other customers, that way, you know you’re making an informed decision for your home or business.

Contact our professional technicians at Hy-Pro Plumbing & Drain Cleaning at 1-877-554-9776 to discuss your hot water tank needs, and let us help you find the right solution. Our customer service team is ready to discuss our complete plumbing services with you today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *